Compare your real Medigap costs: Plan G, Plan N & High-Deductible Plan G
Enter your own quoted premiums and cost assumptions, pick a care scenario, and see the total cost, premiums plus what you would actually pay for care, over 1, 3, 5, 7, and 10 years. A $50 or $100 monthly premium difference becomes serious money over a decade. This tool makes that visible.
Enter your numbers
Your Part B premium and any IRMAA surcharge are the same no matter which Medigap plan you pick — they're here so you can see your full Medicare cost picture, not just the Medigap piece.
Choose a care scenario
Assuming a major medical event every single year isn't realistic — most years are routine. Pick "Realistic Mix" to see a more true-to-life comparison, or choose a single scenario to see what happens if every year looked the same.
Realistic Mix
- Typical care most years
- Frequent care in year 3
- Major medical event in year 7
Typical Year, every year
- 4 quarterly doctor visits
- 1 urgent care visit
Frequent Care, every year
- Doctor visits 2x/month
- 1 outpatient surgery + 12 PT visits
Major Medical Event, every year
- 2 separate hospital stays
- 1 outpatient surgery + 12 PT visits
- Doctor visits 3x/month
See & edit the cost assumptions behind this estimate
These are editable starting assumptions, not a quote. Medicare-approved amounts vary by provider, procedure, and location; actual claims will differ. Plan G and HDG cover Medicare Part B excess charges — Plan N does not, so a provider who doesn't accept Medicare assignment could add cost under Plan N beyond what's modeled here. Every dollar figure above except the Plan N copay now compounds annually at its own rate — see "How this is calculated" below for the full logic and sources.
Your cost comparison
Scenario: Realistic Mix
Premium-only cost (before any care)
Just what you'd pay in premiums — Part B, IRMAA, and your Medigap plan — with the annual increase rates applied, no medical care factored in yet.
Total cost including your care scenario
Premiums (escalating each year) plus what you'd actually pay out of pocket for care in each year of the scenario above.
Year 10 total: premium vs. out-of-pocket
How this is calculated (methodology & sources)
How each plan pays a claim. All three plans sit on top of Original Medicare, which pays 80% of the Medicare-approved amount for Part B services once the Part B deductible is met, and covers Part A hospital costs after the Part A deductible — that doesn't change based on which Medigap plan you own.
- Plan G: you pay the Part B deductible only. Once that's met, Plan G picks up the rest — your 20% Part B coinsurance, the Part A deductible, and Part B excess charges — 100%, for the rest of the year.
- Plan N: you pay the Part B deductible, plus a small copay (default $20) on office and urgent care visits. Everything else — including the Part A deductible and your 20% Part B coinsurance outside those copay visits — is covered. Plan N does not cover Part B excess charges, which this tool doesn't model since they're provider-dependent.
- High-Deductible Plan G: behaves exactly like traditional Medicare cost-sharing until the HDG deductible is satisfied. You pay the Part B deductible, then 20% coinsurance on Part B claims (Medicare is still paying the other 80% the entire time — you're never billed the full charge), plus the Part A deductible if hospitalized — all of it accumulating toward the annual HDG cap. Once your accumulated cost-sharing hits that cap, HDG converts to acting exactly like standard Plan G for the rest of the year: 100% coverage, $0 more out of pocket.
Why the numbers change year to year. Six separate figures compound annually, each at its own rate (all editable above):
- Plan G & Plan N premiums — default 10%/yr
- High-Deductible Plan G premium — default 10%/yr (lower this to model HDG premiums rising more slowly)
- Part B premium / IRMAA — default 0%/yr (recent actual increases: 6% in 2025, ~10% in 2026)
- High-Deductible Plan G annual cap — default 3%/yr, tied to CPI-U by law (history: $2,370 in 2021 → $2,950 in 2026)
- Part B deductible — default 7%/yr (history: $203 in 2021 → $283 in 2026, though it fell slightly in 2023)
- Part A deductible — default 3%/yr (history: $1,600 in 2023 → $1,736 in 2026)
- Medicare-approved service costs (office visit, urgent care, surgery, PT) — default 4%/yr, a general medical-cost-trend estimate
The Plan N copay ($20 default) is held flat since it's a standardized policy term, not a figure CMS adjusts annually.
The "Realistic Mix" timeline. Rather than assuming every year looks identical, this models years 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, and 10 as typical care years, year 3 as a frequent-care year, and year 7 as a major medical event — one heavier stretch and one genuine catastrophic year over a decade, which is closer to how care actually falls for most people than assuming either constant good health or constant crisis.
Sources: CMS 2026 Medicare Parts A & B Premiums, Deductibles, and IRMAA fact sheets (cms.gov); CMS High-Deductible Plan F/G/J Deductible Announcements 2021–2026. Medicare-approved service cost estimates are general planning figures, not published CMS fee schedule line items, and should be treated as illustrative.
About this comparison tool
Which Medigap plan does this tool say is best?
None. The tool is built to show premium versus potential healthcare use versus risk tolerance, not to crown a winner. A plan that wins in a healthy decade can lose in a heavy-care decade, and the right choice depends on your health, budget, and comfort with risk. Once you can see the numbers, we can talk about which strategy actually makes sense for you.
Where do I get the premium quotes to enter?
From real quotes for your age and ZIP code. Medigap premiums vary by carrier, age, and location, so the tool asks for your quoted numbers instead of guessing. We can pull quotes across carriers for you at no cost, and you can bring any quote you have received elsewhere.
Why does the tool include IRMAA and the Part B premium?
Because you pay them no matter which Medigap plan you pick, and they are usually the biggest line item. For 2026 the standard Part B premium is $202.90 per month, and higher incomes pay an IRMAA surcharge on top. Including them shows your true total monthly cost, not just the Medigap premium.
What is the difference between Plan G and Plan N again?
Plan G covers everything Medicare Supplement plans can cover except the annual Part B deductible ($283 for 2026). Plan N trades a lower premium for cost sharing: up to a $20 copay at office visits, up to $50 at the emergency room, and it does not cover Part B excess charges. High-Deductible Plan G works like Plan G but only after you meet its calendar-year deductible.
Are the scenario numbers real claims data?
The three scenarios are illustrative usage patterns (a typical year, a frequent-care year, and a major medical event year) with editable cost assumptions you can change in Step 1. They are meant to make the tradeoffs visible, not to predict your actual spending. Your real costs will differ.
Now that you can see the numbers, let's talk strategy
The tool shows the tradeoffs. Which one actually makes sense depends on your health, your budget, and your comfort with risk, and that conversation is free, with no obligation and no pressure.
- No cost to you
- RSSA® · CMIP®
- No pressure, ever